Here is a table you can use to evaluate and analyse your source of information
Activity : Choose one piece of information you found and try to evaluate it thanks to this table.
Tool to evaluate the reliability of information (from Université de Limoges)
Points | Author | Origin | Objectivity | Source | Date |
3 points | Information comes from a well known or famous organisation. Many professionals participate to its creation | the information is published on a known or reputed professional medium | different arguments and points of view | the author cites and makes available his sources | The source is current |
2 points | the author is qualified in the field concerned | the information is published on a less well-known medium | The author has a bias but exposes various arguments | the author cites his sources without making them available for consultation | the content is less relevant for current data, but still provides a good overview of the subject |
1 point | the author is mentioned but seems unreliable or takes for granted someone else’s work | the information is published on a medium where content can be modified by anyone or is very short (forums, social networks) | Bias with few or without arguments | Author’s opinions only | The information is out of date but it corresponds to my historical work. |
0 point | anonymous | None of the above criteria | Text with bias but claiming objectivity. Only value judgments | No citations | Data are no longer up to date |
NOW add points !
